Bellarmine Chatunga Mugabe, the youngest son of late former Zimbabwe president Robert Mugabe, returned to the Alexandra Magistrates’ Court in Johannesburg on W...
Bellarmine Chatunga Mugabe, the youngest son of late former Zimbabwe president Robert Mugabe, returned to the Alexandra Magistrates’ Court in Johannesburg on Wednesday for sentencing alongside his cousin and co-accused Tobias Matonhodze after both men entered guilty pleas in a case linked to a shooting at a Hyde Park residence.
The case has attracted strong public interest in both Zimbabwe and South Africa because of the Mugabe family name and the seriousness of the charges. Prosecutors are seeking direct imprisonment for the two accused after rejecting calls for non-custodial punishment.
Advertisement
Mugabe pleaded guilty to two offences. The first was pointing what appeared to be a firearm at another person during a separate incident. The second was entering and remaining in South Africa illegally. These admissions formed part of a plea arrangement that removed attempted murder exposure against him.
Matonhodze admitted to more serious offences, including attempted murder after Sipho Mahlangu, an employee at the Johannesburg property, was shot twice in the back during the February incident. He also pleaded guilty to unlawful possession of a firearm, ammunition-related offences, defeating the ends of justice and immigration violations.
State prosecutors previously told the court they wanted Mugabe jailed for 12 months for pointing a firearm and another 12 months for the immigration offence. In Matonhodze’s case, the prosecution asked for a far heavier sentence because of the attempted murder and firearm counts.
During earlier proceedings, investigators told the court the weapon allegedly used in the shooting had not yet been recovered. Police said both accused had not assisted efforts to locate the firearm, an issue prosecutors argued should weigh against leniency at sentencing.
The defence has pushed for suspended sentences or fines. Lawyers argued that both men had no previous convictions and had already made compensation payments to the victim. Court proceedings heard that Mahlangu had received R250,000, with a further R150,000 reportedly still outstanding.
The matter began after the February shooting at Mugabe’s Hyde Park home in Johannesburg. Mugabe and Matonhodze were later arrested and remained in custody as plea discussions between the state and defence continued over several court appearances.
The sentencing decision is expected to determine whether the court prioritises punishment, deterrence or rehabilitation. A custodial sentence would mark a significant legal setback for Mugabe, while a suspended sentence would likely draw close scrutiny because of the profile of the accused.
The case has also revived attention on previous controversies involving members of the Mugabe family in South Africa, adding to the wider political and public interest around the proceedings. However, the current matter is being determined strictly on the charges before the court.
Once sentence is delivered, attention may turn to immigration consequences, particularly for Mugabe after his guilty plea for unlawful entry and residence in South Africa. Any deportation or further administrative process would be handled separately under South African law.
